A Florida couple who gave birth to a child not biologically related to them confirmed they have identified the baby’s genetic parents, ending one chapter in a heartbreaking fertility clinic scandal that raises serious questions about medical oversight and accountability in the reproductive industry.
Shocking Discovery After Birth
Tiffany Score and Steven Mills filed a lawsuit in January against Fertility Center of Orlando and Dr. Milton McNichol, alleging another patient’s embryo was implanted in Score’s uterus in April 2025. The couple, both Caucasian, discovered their now four-month-old daughter Shea displayed physical characteristics indicating she was not biologically related to them. Genetic testing confirmed their worst fears—the baby had no biological connection to either parent. The clinic has announced it will close by May 20.
Parents Committed Despite DNA Results
Despite the devastating revelation, Score and Mills made clear their unwavering commitment to Shea. In a statement obtained by People, the couple declared they will love and parent their daughter forever, regardless of biological connection. They acknowledged the child should legally and morally be united with her genetic parents if those individuals are fit, able, and willing to take custody. Attorney Jack Scarola confirmed the biological parents have not requested custody at this time. The couple stored three viable embryos at the Longwood clinic in 2020.
Unanswered Questions Remain
The fate of Score and Mills’ own embryos remains unknown, raising disturbing possibilities about whether another woman was impregnated with their biological child. The couple expressed frustration that questions about their embryos are now even less likely to be answered given the clinic’s impending closure. Their attorney stated legal proceedings will remain open to address these matters, while also pursuing compensation for expenses incurred and severe emotional trauma. The family will respect the privacy of Shea’s biological parents and keep their identities confidential.
Broader Implications For Fertility Industry
This case highlights critical gaps in oversight and quality control within the fertility industry. The alleged mix-up occurred during in vitro fertilization, a process that creates and stores embryos until pregnancy. The incident raises questions about protocols, safeguards, and accountability measures at fertility clinics nationwide. As the Fertility Center of Orlando prepares to shut down, families affected by potential errors may face additional challenges obtaining answers and justice. The closure decision came after thoughtful consideration by leadership, though the timing raises concerns about outstanding cases and record preservation.